Skip to Main Content
by Vault Law Editors | March 10, 2009

Share

What are the uppers and downers of large consulting firms vs. specialty boutiques vs. policy-focused firms? Here's an easy-to-understand guide.

LARGE MANAGEMENT CONSULTING FIRMS

Uppers

  • Ability to work on a diversity of projects and tasks
  • Intelligent colleagues
  • High pay relative to other entry level jobs in health care
  • Ample opportunity to transition into industry after a two- to 10-year stint

Downers

  • Much longer hours relative to other entry-level jobs in health care
  • Tasks involve difficult analytic thinking performed in relatively short timeframes
  • Need substantial previous experience in health care in order to specialize

Examples: Elites (Strategy)

  • Boston Consulting Group
  • McKinsey & Company
  • Bain & Company

Others (Strategy, Operations, Systems):

  • Deloitte and Touche
  • Andersen Consulting
  • PriceWaterhouseCoopers
  • Ernst & Young

BOUTIQUE FIRMS

Uppers

  • Smaller office might mean more responsibility and client contact for recent graduates
  • Easy ability to gain skills in a specific line of work ? these skills may be effectively marketed to larger consulting firms or potential industry employers
  • Flexibility in terms of how long you want to stay (as opposed to the two- to three-year, "up or out" philosophy of some large consulting firms)
  • Health care work only

~Downers

  • Fewer formalized processes make it very easy to be ?out of the loop? on significant issues related to personnel and office politics
  • Less diversity in the range of projects and tasks you will encounter
  • Tend to be less stable financially than larger firms ? often run by individuals who are new to the pressures and rewards of running the own consulting firm
  • Entry-level consultants are often paid less than at larger firms

Other key factors

  • Tend to specialize in one line of products, services or clients
  • Tend to be congregated in Washington DC, Boston and the West Coast
  • Often started by individuals recently leaving industry or larger consulting firms

POLICY- AND RESEARCH-FOCUSED FIRMS

Uppers

  • More scientifically rigorous, publishable work
  • Good non-MBA graduate school opportunities
  • Fewer hours than most other consultants
Downers
  • Less pay than most large management consulting firms
  • May get labeled a ?data person? and never see the light of day

Major players

  • The Lewin Group, Inc.
  • Abt Associates, Inc.
  • Covance, Inc.
  • Mathematica Research, Inc.

Share

Filed Under: Law

Want to be found by top employers? Upload Your Resume

Join Gold to Unlock Company Reviews

Newsletter
Subscribe to the Vault
Newsletter

Be the first to read new articles and get updates from the Vault team.